Talking Grammar . . . in the Wall Street Journal

Ever wonder why grammar matters? You may find my column for the Wall Street Journal worth a glance:

Welcome Back, My Ungrammatical Students

15 comments:

  1. Just read your Op-Ed piece in WSJ - I wish college students were receiving remedial English. I interview students with college degrees who can't even form a paragraph.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Can't access WSJ article w/o subscribing

    ReplyDelete
  3. 6th paragraph of the article: "Based on three decades of teaching English prep courses, I can assure you this is a safe supposition since no more than one in a hundred remedial students can define the term 'clause.'"
    Doesn't this sentence contain an ungrammatically dangling participle? (The antecedent of "based" is "I," but you are not based on three decades of teaching, even if perhaps by metonymy you are because your opinion is.)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous September 4, 2013 at 12:47 PM

      makes sense to me.

      Delete
    2. "Based on" could easily mean the preposition "after" or some other introductory word like participle "relying on..."; I think antecedents have more to do with pronoun agreement. Don't you need an adjective in front of "dangling participle," a term thought of as a whole? What in the world does your pedantic use of the word "metonymy" mean in this context?

      Delete
  4. God Bless you Mr. Goldblatt for this commentary. I've started a running meme on my Facebook page called "Grammar Police!" Every time I find a grammatical error of extreme proportion in a printed (usually news) source, I put it on my Facebook page for my friends and family to enjoy. While teaching our students better grammar from the start is certainly a noble endeavor on your part, I'd argue that we need to hold our professional writers to a higher standard, too. There should be a place for public shaming (beyond just my personal Facebook page) for every news writer (or book writer or what have you) and editor that allows horrible grammar to make it to web pages, magazines and newspapers. What's the point of encouraging proper grammar in school if students turn around and read sloppy grammar on CNN.com or FoxNews.com or in Time Magazine or the Wall Street Journal?

    ReplyDelete
  5. I wonder why you selected only 4 dead black men as your examples. Their era is not ours. Their style is not ours. Are you addressing only black men? Not women? Not non-black men? Are only black men in the remedial English classes? What is it you infer? Marj Helmer mhelmer.author@gmail.com Faribault, MN

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You meant "imply," not "infer." You, Marj, are doing the inferring.

      Delete
  6. Aquí hay un reloj Rolex Daytona réplica que me disparó hace un tiempo. Como he dicho antes Daytonas están entre los modelos más populares de relojes de réplica de todos los tiempos. Además, tengo un video adicional de replicas relojes espana otro Daytona. Creo que sin demasiadas dudas de cualquiera de ustedes, la Rolex Daytona ofrece más cuando se trata de variedad. Sin duda, parece que los brotes de Daytona la mayoría de los colores, materiales y combinaciones de estilo que cualquier otro modelo Rolex. Vintage o edición nueva o especial o diamantes o costumbre o sólo alguna otra combinación nueva que surgió con tanto tiempo como cae en el diseño de replicas rolex Daytona va a ser una Rolex Daytona y es simplemente imposible saber todas las versiones y combinaciones que fueron siempre hecho.

    Un conocido cercano de la mina combinado para la réplica de los relojes conmigo y algunos amigos y tiene esta replicas breitling reloj en algún momento de esta primavera. Un reloj de acero inoxidable muy bueno que mira todo de buena calidad. Reloj falso crujiente agradable con el dial bien clonado, los números, las manos y los cronógrafos. Grabados Rolex en la caja interior, logotipo en la corona y un bisel bien hecho atrapar su ojo a primera vista. Impulsado por un movimiento automático japonés automático, el reloj mantiene el tiempo bien y es preciso. La pulsera cuenta con acero pulido y pulido. También, tiene tornillos para la eliminación fácil del acoplamiento. El caso es pulido y bien clonado también. El logotipo Rolex también está presente en replicas omega el cierre plegable y también hay grabados en la parte posterior de él también.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Get your Finance Assignment Help, Homework, Project Help Online for Students in UK, USA, and Australia by Professional finance writers at affordable prices.
    Finance Assignments Help

    ReplyDelete
  8. Get your Finance Assignment Help, Homework, Project Help Online for Students in UK, USA, and Australia by Professional finance writers at affordable prices.

    ReplyDelete
  9. The blog is sensationally wonderful. Simply cherish the way how all the written work has been put.Joseph Hayon

    ReplyDelete