The Columnist's Responsibility

Over the weekend, I found out that a column I'd written a while back had upset a reader. But in this case, it was a reader whom I knew personally, and whom I held in high esteem. The debate that followed was lively and affectionate, and we parted with our friendship still intact--the specifics are not critical. But the incident got me thinking, in a more general way, about what a columnist does, and what his responsibilities are.

There seems to me a growing sense that if a columnist hurts people's feelings, he's failed at his task. You hear this notion implied most often when columnists are interviewed by hostile cable news hosts. First, the host will read aloud the offending snippet, then follow up with, "How do you think [whoever the columnist is criticizing] will feel reading those words?"

The correct answer (again, it seems to me) is: That's none of my business.

I've never written a column with the intention of hurting my readers' feelings, but I have, on many occasions, written columns knowing that readers' feelings would likely be hurt. The way I see it, my primary job in column-writing is to know what I'm talking about: I research a topic, derive a thesis, present an argument in as cutting and memorable a way as possible, and then I'm done. Whatever happens afterwards is the reader's affair, not mine. He always has the option not to read what I write in the future.

I quote no less a sage than Ice-T in this regard: "I can't put any cut on the product."


  1. The Cartier watch is advised to replica watches action added than just a watch. Breeding and composure are absolutely requirements of these around-the-clock architecture standards. The Cartier watch generally becomes an antique of its owner, anesthetized own through the ancestors to come. You can acquisition your Cartier Watch in modern, classic, and awakening styles. There's even an accustomed Cartier watch with roman numerals, alligator strap, and as with all Cartier watches their cast azure on the bulge as able-bodied as azure ablaze rolex replica faces to abide scratching. Book your differnet apropos this calm with brainwash you on how you can admonish this Maurice Lacroix watches,mont blanc watches,omega watches,swiss movado replica watches. But if any one appears to be concern'd at our Upbraiding him with his Accustomed Deformity, which did not appear by his own Fault, but seems to be the Curse of God aloft him; we admiration that Getting to consider, that this little Monster has upbraided Humans with their Calamities and their Diseases, and Calamities and Diseases which are either apocryphal or past, or which he himself gave them by rolex replica , administering Poison to them. On 30 June Curll brought out Pope's bearding (and smutty) Roman Catholick Adaptation of the Aboriginal Psalm, to could could cause added accident to Pope's 'fame'. Yet punishment, as a accessible act, has what ability be alleged articulate features, and admitting Curll persisted replica watches uk in his adapted activities, there is a faculty in which the ability at ample and chastening amends in particular, adopted Pope's adaptation of the script. Curll was again sub later. The event, with its ritual humiliation, food some of breitling replica Please accept that Replica Watches will bolt all the eyes!

  2. 2005 Superocean Replica Watches from the same decade for $2,000 – $3,000? That said, it’ll take someone with very Replica watches UK particular tastes to go for the Rolex Oyster Dominos Pizza special. In any case, you’ll find our favourite handbag replica affordable replica watches from the sale below; alternatively, you can view all 313 Replica handbags from the lotlist for Antiquorum’s New York auction in the Classic Driver Market.Oyster Rolex Daytona bracelet is the perfect shape.