REVIEW: The Politically Incorrect Guide to American History

The New York Post

THE POLITICALLY INCORRECT GUIDE TO AMERICAN HISTORY
by Thomas Woods
(Regnery: Washington DC, 2004)

reviewed by

Mark Goldblatt
March 20, 2005


It would be possible to write a history of America focusing on the cruelty of the Indians towards European settlers and their descendants, citing broken treaties, kidnappings, and assorted massacres of white women and children. Such a book would be factually correct but would miss the forest for the trees--since the wide angle view cannot avoid the genocidal upheavals visited upon the Indians, intentionally and unintentionally, by whites. On the outskirts of the political left, Howard Zinn is notable for an overriding forest-trees problem; his determination to highlight every instance of ethnic minorities and working poor being exploited by wealthy capitalists blinds him to the long-term trend in American history towards greater social justice.

Thomas Woods should be understood as the far right’s answer to Howard Zinn. The first chapter of Woods’s new book The Politically Incorrect Guide to American History sets the tone. While he doesn’t deny the “injustice and maltreatment” of Indians throughout American history, he notes that during the colonial period Harvard College admitted Indian students, that colonists “could and did receive the death penalty for murdering Indians” and that Indian converts to Christianity “enjoyed considerable autonomy.” The qualifier “considerable” is telling; Woods is cherry picking facts. It’s true, as he asserts, that Indians were quite cognizant of land ownership; for millennia, they’d fought tribal wars over disputed territories, so they knew what selling their land to whites meant. But Woods skirts the fact that such sales were often made under duress. If relations between the groups were hunky-dory, then why, in 1643, did whites form the Confederation of New England “in case of conflict with the Indians”?

Woods’s take on the forty year run up to the Civil War has the southern states essentially minding their own business, enduring multiple provocations from the North, until finally they felt compelled to secede. Well, maybe, but the business they were minding was slaveholding. That’s the forest. The trees are that the motives for North’s actions were not altogether altruistic, that John Brown might’ve received financial support from New England abolitionists, and that the southern states had a plausible constitutional right to secede. Woods misses the idea that wars of narrow self-interest occasionally morph into grand moral causes--as is happening, even now, in the Middle East. If you overlook the moral component of the Civil War, you might as well argue that the U.S. had no quarrel with the Nazis because Germany had been screwed by the Treaty of Versailles after World War One.

Sorry, that’s Chapter Thirteen.

This isn’t to say that Woods has written a worthless book. His analysis of the dubious benefits of antitrust legislation is strong, as is his take on the financial policies leading to the Depression; he does a good job rehabilitating Presidents Harding and Coolidge and taking FDR down a peg. Woods is generally on more solid ground talking about economics than about ethics. Indeed, he never comes to grips with the notion that history and morality are bound together, and that winding up on the side of the angels--the side of Jefferson’s self-evident truths--counts.

45 comments:

  1. Standing up for your rights is not considered to be coward thing that you must need to anticipate wit your consideration and raise your voice for rights, if things are also going with political reviews, there might not be any chances of general public survival. assignment help australia

    ReplyDelete
  2. if things are also going with political reviews, there might not be any chances of general public survival.

    Thanks for Sharing That... Sucses for You

    CARMAGAZINEE

    FILEHIPPO

    ReplyDelete
  3. I would like to say thank you for the amazing details and concepts you are sharing in this.
    Female Gurgaon Escorts Services

    ReplyDelete
  4. I am very much pleased with the contents you have mentioned. I wanted to thank you for this great blog.
    Female Gurgaon Escort Services

    ReplyDelete
  5. Howdy, Nice post, This is uncommonly intriguing and astonishing. Such an assortment of people like this blog section and me. Get considerably more information your blog passage. Thankful to you for conferring post to us.
    Delhi Escorts , BeautyEscorts in Delhi By Anushka Roy

    ReplyDelete
  6. I satisfied in finished analysis your weblog site accessibility. Your weblog have pleasant details, I got brilliant concepts from this awesome web book. I am regularly looking like this type weblog accessibility. I believe in I will see again .
    Independent Escorts in Gurgaon |
    IndependentEscorts in Delhi |
    Escorts in Delhi |
    http://www.gurugramnightangel.com/ |
    Escorts in Aerocity |
    Escorts in Gurgaon, Gurgaon Escorts Service

    ReplyDelete
  7. I would like to say thank you for the amazing details
    target black friday coupons
    http://www.wowpromocodes.com/

    ReplyDelete

  8. Gurgaon Escorts
    Escorts in Gurgaonis one of the most colorful and cultural city of Call Girl in Gurgaon and since it is the capital city, providing ample opportunities Gurgaon Escort Service for various sectors including jobs, is a must here. Female Escorts in Gurgaon There are numerous good universities here which attracts students from all over the world and apart from that it is also emerging as one of the peaceful and safest city to work in. Independent Escorts in GurgaonLooking at all these parameters, many people come to this city with a dream and most of them are able to achieve them with some efforts.
    Escorts in Gurgaon Service

    ReplyDelete
  9. The blog is really awesome always post informative posts and its continuously improving my knowledge Acer Customer Services

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks for sharing this important article with us.
    Dell Customer Service

    ReplyDelete
  11. very informative article!
    thanks for sharing.
    Apple Support

    ReplyDelete
  12. Amazing post and please keep posting like this.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Great work! Totally motivating and inspiring.Keep sharing such more in future also.Thank you so much. Yahoo Tech Support

    ReplyDelete
  14. It's very informative Blog, it's more helpful to us thanks for sharing keep it up!!! Firefox Customer Care Number

    ReplyDelete
  15. It's very informative Blog, it's more helpful to us thanks for sharing keep it up!!! Internet Explorer Support

    ReplyDelete
  16. Chrome Customer ServiceThanks for sharing such an important article with us.

    ReplyDelete
  17. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Really very useful post. It will surely help me in live communication with clients. Thanks a lot for this awesome post!
    Chrome Customer Support

    ReplyDelete
  19. i find this post very informative. thanks for sharing this post with us.
    <a href="http://routercustomersupport.snack.ws/ Asus Router Contact Number</a>

    ReplyDelete
  20. chrome support
    It's very informative Blog, it's more helpful to us thanks for sharing keep it up

    ReplyDelete
  21. This hookup app is in fashion nowadays and getting very popular among the young generation. The HAPPN app helps us to find the casual partner for spending some quality time. Hookup Apps

    ReplyDelete
  22. great post so thanks for this because this is the amazing.
    iphone Phone Number

    ReplyDelete