REVIEW: The Politically Incorrect Guide to American History

The New York Post

THE POLITICALLY INCORRECT GUIDE TO AMERICAN HISTORY
by Thomas Woods
(Regnery: Washington DC, 2004)

reviewed by

Mark Goldblatt
March 20, 2005


It would be possible to write a history of America focusing on the cruelty of the Indians towards European settlers and their descendants, citing broken treaties, kidnappings, and assorted massacres of white women and children. Such a book would be factually correct but would miss the forest for the trees--since the wide angle view cannot avoid the genocidal upheavals visited upon the Indians, intentionally and unintentionally, by whites. On the outskirts of the political left, Howard Zinn is notable for an overriding forest-trees problem; his determination to highlight every instance of ethnic minorities and working poor being exploited by wealthy capitalists blinds him to the long-term trend in American history towards greater social justice.

Thomas Woods should be understood as the far right’s answer to Howard Zinn. The first chapter of Woods’s new book The Politically Incorrect Guide to American History sets the tone. While he doesn’t deny the “injustice and maltreatment” of Indians throughout American history, he notes that during the colonial period Harvard College admitted Indian students, that colonists “could and did receive the death penalty for murdering Indians” and that Indian converts to Christianity “enjoyed considerable autonomy.” The qualifier “considerable” is telling; Woods is cherry picking facts. It’s true, as he asserts, that Indians were quite cognizant of land ownership; for millennia, they’d fought tribal wars over disputed territories, so they knew what selling their land to whites meant. But Woods skirts the fact that such sales were often made under duress. If relations between the groups were hunky-dory, then why, in 1643, did whites form the Confederation of New England “in case of conflict with the Indians”?

Woods’s take on the forty year run up to the Civil War has the southern states essentially minding their own business, enduring multiple provocations from the North, until finally they felt compelled to secede. Well, maybe, but the business they were minding was slaveholding. That’s the forest. The trees are that the motives for North’s actions were not altogether altruistic, that John Brown might’ve received financial support from New England abolitionists, and that the southern states had a plausible constitutional right to secede. Woods misses the idea that wars of narrow self-interest occasionally morph into grand moral causes--as is happening, even now, in the Middle East. If you overlook the moral component of the Civil War, you might as well argue that the U.S. had no quarrel with the Nazis because Germany had been screwed by the Treaty of Versailles after World War One.

Sorry, that’s Chapter Thirteen.

This isn’t to say that Woods has written a worthless book. His analysis of the dubious benefits of antitrust legislation is strong, as is his take on the financial policies leading to the Depression; he does a good job rehabilitating Presidents Harding and Coolidge and taking FDR down a peg. Woods is generally on more solid ground talking about economics than about ethics. Indeed, he never comes to grips with the notion that history and morality are bound together, and that winding up on the side of the angels--the side of Jefferson’s self-evident truths--counts.

14 comments:

  1. Standing up for your rights is not considered to be coward thing that you must need to anticipate wit your consideration and raise your voice for rights, if things are also going with political reviews, there might not be any chances of general public survival. assignment help australia

    ReplyDelete
  2. Extremely incredible article, Glad to peruse the article. It is instructive for us. A debt of gratitude is in order for posting.

    norton.com/setup | norton.com/setup | mcafee.com/activate | norton.com/setup | mcafee.com/activate

    ReplyDelete
  3. Norton gives protection from the majority of the dangers that endure in the advanced domain. To get Norton setup, go to norton.com/setup.
    Feel Free to contact us:
    norton.com/setup|norton.com/setup|norton.com/setup

    ReplyDelete
  4. Mcafee Product Activation online using the internet is easy. Go to the official site and purchase it. Save it, run it and pass through some easy instruction and agree with all the policies. When you open, it shows an alert about Activation.

    mcafee.com/activate
    mcafee.com/activate
    mcafee.com/activate
    mcafee.com/activate
    mcafee.com/activate

    ReplyDelete
  5. Assignment Help services offers quality and plagiarism-free work for students to acquire good grades on their subjects. If you are about to miss your due dates, login to greatassignmenthelp and complete your work on time.
    Assignment Help Online
    Online Assignment Help
    Assignment Help Online Services
    Assignment Helper
    Assignment Assistance
    Assignment Help Experts
    Online Assignment Help Services

    ReplyDelete
  6. I really happy found this website eventually. Really informative and inoperative, Thanks for the post and effort! Please keep sharing more such blog.

    norton.com/setup

    norton.com/setup

    mcafee.com/activate

    kaspersky activation code

    free pogo games

    roadrunner email

    aol mail

    ReplyDelete
  7. I really happy found this website eventually. Really informative and inoperative, Thanks for the post and effort! Please keep sharing more such blog.

    norton.com/setup

    norton.com/setup

    mcafee.com/activate

    kaspersky activation code

    free pogo games

    roadrunner email

    aol mail

    ReplyDelete
  8. The HP printer support number which we have here is the best phone number to connect with the technical support team.

    ReplyDelete
  9. One can use wps pin for establishing wireless connection to network in a hand-free way. To use such Pin, you should first open the input tray, then press and hold both the button Wi-Fi on/off and the Wi-Fi connect option on the scanner simultaneously for at least two to three seconds. After that release both the options at the same if you see the Wi-Fi on/off light flashes blue. Enter the PIN code on the wireless router or access point to connect to a network. For more easiest and effectual procedures of accessing the WPS PIN code, you are required to get in touch with tech-specialists via dialing the helpline number. They are the right person for any kind of your printer regarding problems.https://www.hpprintersupportpro.com/blog/find-wps-pin-on-hp-printer-and-establish-connection/

    ReplyDelete
  10. The proprietorship firm registration type of business is the popular form of marketing for
    small entrepreneurs. It just makes from a company with a small capital, a short time. It requires a
    straightforward process with minimum legal compliances and training costs. Traditionally, the
    individual is the best way to set up a small business on a large scale for most business people.
    The main features of this type of business identify the other types.
    1. Proprietorship requires a person and is essentially a one-man show.
    2. Because of the involvement of one person and legal complacency minimum, it is much easier
    to start and dissolve the company. https://www.filingbazaar.com/service/proprietorship-firm-registration

    ReplyDelete
  11. When your canon printer’s status shows, “canon printer in error state” there may be some errors with your printing machine. This error is one of the toughest problems that can make you more annoying. There may be many reasons of this error. If you don’t find suitable solutions, you can choose us as a reliable third party support provider. If you’re facing this error again and again, our printer experts are trained and experienced to solve canon printer in error state completely from the origin. Our helpline number is open 24/7 to provide immediate support for any difficulty.

    ReplyDelete
  12. 'I'm highly impressed by the piece of thoughts you have shared on this portal. all the best
    connect us on Assignment Help can shed your burden of assignments with a return of qualitative assignments.

    ReplyDelete